Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
©2009 *AtomicStoney
:iconatomicstoney:

Artist's Comments

Another commission done, this time for ~soan, of his character Alice.

This pose was a lot of fun to draw, and I had a lot of fun coloring it. c:


...I think it's safe to assume that I'm addicted to drawing holes in jeans.

Character "Alice" © ~soan
Art © Stoney 2009
[drawn and inked in Open Canvas 1.1, colored in Photoshop 7.0]

Critiques


:iconsetstage:
The Good:
I like the anatomy in this work, along with the pose, they are both very nice. The expression is spot on as well. The colour scheme works great and has great unity. I like the subtle use of detailed and slightly varied lines to define the shape. The level of detail is great too. I love the use of cool shading on the white and black. It keeps the character neutral.

The Bad:
I see a misconception of value and form. There are just a few lighting inconsistencies, is what I mean. I mentioned how I liked the cool shading, but the red pants have a warmer shading, and it is distracting because it jumps out at you, and probably isn't meant to be the visual focus of the piece. The character looks barely grounded and still as though its floating.

Vision:
I don't get a message or a point to this. It just is a character, this isn't a bad thing, but when rating the vision behind the piece I have to say it isn't exactly visionary.

Originality:
Where it lacks in vision it makes up in originality, even though its just a character drawing, it has a great bit of personality. You have a knack for infusing your personality into all your drawings.

Technique:
As I mentioned there are inconsistencies in the placement of shades. This is looked over though because your use of the medium is stunning, and it shows your proficiency in your craft. The shades and highlights look BEAUTIFUL, just kind of misplaced.

Impact:
This piece will probably fade from my memory, even though I like it I feel that it does not have much staying power. I great picture for someone to look at, learn a bit from, but ultimately move on to more "finished" deviations.

Didn't Read:
7/10 Good job even if kinda forget able, look to creating a more final piece next time
The Artist thought this was FAIR
9 out of 10 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 1 1 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconpuppyakamaru:
oh wow!

--
:salute: I'm a proud Risembool Ranger who lobves our Fuhrer Vic Mignogna. If you're an official Ranger, copy & paste this in your sig.

Mother Earth is crying over her children but nobody listens.
It’s the hour of the wolf and there is no return.
:iconkonicoon:
again you kick my works ass. i wish that i can do that kind of detail.

--
i want to be there to help you, but i can never have the courage to do it.
:iconduo2nd:
Wow Stoney! You really do well at these drawings.

--
I am Pokemon #490 Manaphy in DA's Pokemon Crew

You called?
:iconsoan:
Again, love the coloring. It's awesome. It really brings out Alice.
:iconbloodking71:
So awesome! She's so beatiful :heart:~

--
Madness uh? This... is... SPARTAN!!!
:iconatomicstoney:
You're very welcome. :)

--
If at first you don't succeed, kill the one who did.
:iconatomicstoney:
Thank you. :)

--
If at first you don't succeed, kill the one who did.
:iconwolfenlied:
Nice. :D

--
Contrary to popular belief, failing at failing does not make you a success.
:iconmotavated:
You know what. I like how the boobs show with the affect of the lighting and how it crease in. BUT! She the shirt is loose, so those crease should not show up in RL. Just being picky since you wanted a critique. Its really nice really!

If you really want to get people attention or the men. You should of used her finger to pull the neck of the shirt a little down. It makes her more flirty! Or draw the shirt more down to show some cleavage. HEHEHEHEHEH!

--
:moo: Mooo...

Details

May 10
293 KB
94.0 KB
600×1102

Statistics

23
97 [who?]
1,269 (0 today)
0 (0 today)

Share

Link
Embed
Thumb

Site Map